An extension can understand the current webpage more directly, while a desktop recorder can move between the browser, Finder, and native apps.
The core tradeoff
Choose a macro recorder for cross-app visual workflows and an extension for browser-only tasks that benefit from page-aware controls.
When MacroLoop is the better fit
MacroLoop is a strong option when the workflow crosses applications or extensions cannot be installed. It records the same visible path the user performs.
When an extension wins
Use a page-aware extension when controls move, data changes, or the process needs selectors and conditions. Review extension permissions carefully.
THE TAKEAWAY
Choose cross-app reach or page awareness according to the real workflow.